CIA put forward by Granger is widely used in corpus-based study, but what is the difference between CIA and CA?
Is CIA and CA similar to each other?
- 主题发起人 pepsi_blue
- 时间
回复: Is CIA and CA similar to each other?
You already know the difference: "I" is missing in CA.
CA: Contrastive Analysis (contrastive linguistics, or cross-linguistic contrast) is concerned with different native languages (L1).
CIA: Contrastive Interlanguage Analysis is clearly about the learner' interlanguage - their knowledge and production of the second/foreign language being learnt (L2).
You may wish to read the following paper to find out what I think about that:
http://www.lancs.ac.uk/postgrad/xiaoz/papers/IJELT_paper.zip
You already know the difference: "I" is missing in CA.
CA: Contrastive Analysis (contrastive linguistics, or cross-linguistic contrast) is concerned with different native languages (L1).
CIA: Contrastive Interlanguage Analysis is clearly about the learner' interlanguage - their knowledge and production of the second/foreign language being learnt (L2).
You may wish to read the following paper to find out what I think about that:
http://www.lancs.ac.uk/postgrad/xiaoz/papers/IJELT_paper.zip
Haiyang Ai
Administrator
回复: Is CIA and CA similar to each other?
Yes, if you're dealing with learner corpus, then you might need to digg into CIA.
Yes, if you're dealing with learner corpus, then you might need to digg into CIA.
回复: Is CIA and CA similar to each other?
Thank u all for your explanations. It is really a great forum that helps me a lot with my thesis.
Thank u all for your explanations. It is really a great forum that helps me a lot with my thesis.
回复: Is CIA and CA similar to each other?
How does the CIA differ from CEA since both of them deal with under-overused phenomena? thank you!
How does the CIA differ from CEA since both of them deal with under-overused phenomena? thank you!